Ask Papabear: The First Advice Column for Furries!
  • Home
  • Letters
  • Write Me
  • Disclaimer
  • Advertise
  • About
  • Testimonials
  • Fan Art
  • Good Furry Award
  • Home
  • Letters
  • Write Me
  • Disclaimer
  • Advertise
  • About
  • Testimonials
  • Fan Art
  • Good Furry Award

You and the Furry Fandom (Editorial)

1/1/2024

9 Comments

 
Dear Readers,

I'd like to begin this year, if you will indulge me, with a little editorial on my thoughts about the fandom and being a furry in general.

This year, Papabear will turn 59, which is the age that my late husbear, Jim, died, so you might imagine this is cause for reflection for me. Also, I am trying very hard to finish my book about the furry fandom, so it is a year for a couple of milestones for me. SO MUCH has changed in the fandom since I began researching my book way back in 2015! SO MUCH has changed since I started this advice column in 2012! Heck, so much has changed in general. I'm also thinking a lot about what furry means to me and where the fandom is going.

In human society (at least, in the American society with which I am intimately familiar), we go through the following stages in life:

  1. Ages 0-20 are spent learning about the world and how to function in it and what society's expectations are of us (e.g., i.e., how to be a good little citizen/son/daughter/ wife/husband/father/mother)
  2. Ages 21-40 we are busy fulfilling those expectations by getting married, buying a car, getting a job, buying a house, having children, climbing the corporate ladder to "success."
  3. Ages 41-60 (if we make it, especially, but also if we don't) we start questioning all these "accomplishments" because we find them to be very unfulfilling, so we start searching for who we really are. This is often called a "midlife crisis."
  4. Ages 61 to death: If we stuck with the status quo, we look toward retirement and remaining years doing expected stuff such as taking cruises and golfing until we end up in a rest home and wait to die. If we didn't, we might have a few years left to revel in enjoying being ourselves before we grow sick and die.

The above is a generalization, of course, but it is the basic pattern I see in our society.

But what if we refused to follow that pattern? What if, after figuring out what the world is about (e.g., being a nice little cog in the Wheel of Society), we reject this paradigm, skip Phase 2, fast-forward Phase 3, and enjoy the self-actualization of Phase 4 from our 20s all the way until death?

That, for me, is what the furry fandom is about in many ways: exploring the TRUE YOU through imaginative play and creativity, free from all the constraints that enslave the unhappy throngs that imprison most of the population.

When Jim was still alive, we would go to cons together (he wasn't a furry, but he was very supportive just like my current husband, Michael). I think it was at MFF (c. 2011, I believe) when he made an observation that struck me as quite perceptive. "Kevin," he said, "these furries are an awful lot like the hippies in the Sixties." In other words, this isn't just a fandom, it's a countercultural movement.

Admittedly, there are a lot of furries who just indulge in the fandom for its shock value and for something to do because "they're bored." I've heard quite a few young people say that. They are the kind of furries who leave the fandom when they eventually buy into Phase 2.

For the rest of us, furry is a way to shed all those expectations, requirements, judgments, and rules imposed upon us by society. Being an anthro is the overt way of expressing rebellion for human ways, but internally we are also searching for secret doors to passages that will allow us to escape the predetermined molds into which we are expected to fit.

This is why it is ironic when certain furries try to impose rules designed to judge whether or not you are a "real furry." This is totally counter to the spirit of the fandom, which is iconoclastic at its very core.

Some of these gatekeepers are from the Old Guard (furries who've been around 30-40 years or so) who don't like how the fandom has changed. Well, it's OK for it to change. If it didn't, it would become stagnant and soon die.

Some of these gatekeepers are newer to the fandom, but they impose "rules" in order to set themselves up as the "real furries" who are in charge and get to tell others what is right or wrong about the fandom. They usually seek power and influence because they are trying to hide their own low self-esteem by putting others down.

Don't listen to either group.

What makes the furry fandom different from all other fandoms is that it is the members of this fandom who determine its nature, not some TV or movie franchise, not some corporate entity like Paramount or Lucas Films or Disney, and not even some nonprofit organization.

No. WE make the fandom what it is today, and WE will make it what it will be tomorrow.

No rules. Just play.

Play is important. Don't disregard the value of play. Avoid the people who want to take the play away.

Changes in the fandom are accelerating exponentially. We can look forward to many developments as the fandom continues to grow, gets influenced by outside cultural changes, and finds new opportunities for expression through advancing technologies. By 2034 it might not even be recognizable compared to 2024. I know it has changed considerably since 2014, so I expect even greater changes in another 10 years.

Here's the point (in case you were wondering): If you came to the fandom as a way to escape the doldrums and judgment of mainstream society and better express yourself; if you came here to find furiends like yourself; then don't worry about whether or not you fit in and what rules you must follow. You DO fit in and there are NO RULES except the ones you write for yourself.

This fandom is for YOU not some verkokte gatekeeper. 

Oh, and BUCKLE UP! The next 10 years are going to be a WILD RIDE!

Happy New Year!

​Papabear
9 Comments
Earl Bacon link
1/1/2024 12:55:35 pm

You and I are the same age and have been in this Fandom just as long. I agree with all you have written. May your 2024 be a good one.

Reply
Papabear
1/1/2024 01:35:23 pm

Thank you!!

Reply
Equuinoxxx link
1/1/2024 01:10:02 pm

Well said! I couldn't agree more and I appreciate your positive acceptance and embrace of change in the furry fandom! Happy new year to you and yours, Kevin! Love you!

Reply
Papabear
1/1/2024 01:35:07 pm

Thank you!

Reply
Adam Thomas Applebaum link
1/1/2024 01:25:12 pm

Thank you for this informative post. Due to some of the scandals that have happened in the past almost 10 years I've been in this Fandom I start to kind of understand why two different sides gatekeep.

There's always been a side that wants Furry to be seen as safe for kids and due to the lack of media literacy nowadays, there's a growing intolerance for symbolic expression of hidden narratives. Some things must be told and not shown or they perceive the worst. I do not want to gatekeep, but I've always been of the mind that if you can't tolerate fiction as fiction regardless what's in it you're just pretending to be Furry.

To illustrate the point in the most safe for work way possible, some of the Fandom members today actually think Thomas Hobbs wanted us to eat the children of the poor and pay the parents for it like they were some common meat source and think cannibals are just like us religiously except they eat people. See the "A Modest Proposal" book.

Anyways I come to realize the urge to gatekeep on either side of the spectrum is very much a defense mechanism for people, so I endeavor to try and see where everyone's coming from whenever possible. I just wish they'd grant me the same.

Anywho my condolences for the loss and if you need someone to talk to I'm around and can communicate however is most comfortable for you. I understand you'll have my email in your database once this post goes up.

Reply
Papabear
1/1/2024 01:33:48 pm

Hi,
Thanks for the comment. Oh, I think you mean Jonathan Swift, not Thomas Hobbes.

Reply
Adam Thomas Applebaum link
1/25/2024 06:48:56 pm

That is possible that I confused them, nevertheless I stand by what I said that fictional content does not cause behaviors that happen in it to become real and fictional content should not be taken as an allegory to any real plots by anyone to do anything or an opinion of what should actually be a solution to very real problems. Rather there needs to be room to presume it satire if it seems really out there or at the very least not something that ought to be applied to reality.

Critter link
1/1/2024 05:12:39 pm

Great post, Grubbs!

Not sure about chicken and the egg issue, though. I've always lived a bit off the 'norm' and when I first ran across the furry world online in the late 90s it was a natural fit (alt.lifestyle.furry, anyone?). It's been a fun romp and only wish there were a few more old furs who escaped the cruises and golf courses.

Best to all furs in 2024!

- Critter, Not Dead Yet

Reply
Acton (Richard)
1/21/2024 10:30:49 pm

Very true, I agree with you Mr. Papabear.
"What makes the furry fandom different from all other fandoms is that it is the members of this fandom who determine its nature, not some TV or movie franchise, not some corporate entity like Paramount or Lucas Films or Disney, and not even some nonprofit organization.

No. WE make the fandom what it is today, and WE will make it what it will be tomorrow."
We make the fandom. I would add even a furry influencer after nonprofit organization.

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Go to Papabear's Facebook page

    RSS Feed

    Categories

    All
    Addiction
    Art And Literature
    Careers
    Coming Out Furry
    Crime And The Law
    Editorial
    Family Issues
    Friends Issues
    Furcons And Furmeets
    Furry Definition
    Furry Issues (other)
    Fursonas
    Fursuiting
    Health
    Illness And Death Issues
    LGBT And Gender Issues
    Loneliness Depression Anger
    Love And Relationships
    Money
    Odd And Ends
    Politics
    Religion And Spirituality
    Roommates
    School Life
    Self Improvement
    Sexuality And Sex
    Social Networking
    Work And The Workplace

    Picture
    Picture
    An excellent article on coming out LGBT to Christian parents.
    Picture
    My Rainbow Ark is a site for and about LGBT furries and religion and how they are not incompatible.

    Picture
    A note on comments: Comments on letters to Papabear are welcome, especially those that offer extra helpful advice and add something to the conversation that is of use to the letter writer and those reading this column. Also welcome are constructive criticisms and opposing views. What is NOT welcome are hateful, hurtful comments, flaming, and trolling. Such comments will be deleted from this site. Thank you.

Home

Letters

Write Me

Disclaimer

About

Copyright © 2012-2024